Skip to content

Outrage grows over 'intoxication defence' ruling

The Sexual Assault Support Centre of Waterloo Region calls it 'disheartening'
Stock photo

On June 3, The Court of Appeal for Ontario ruled in favour of changing a law that barred self-induced intoxication as a defence in cases of sexual assault and other violent crimes. 

Since the ruling became public, many people, organizations, and political figures have been rallying against the decision. 

TK Pritchard, Public Education Manager with the Sexual Assault Support Centre of Waterloo Region, said they are very disappointed with this change. 

"We already are in a world of sexual violence where we struggle with appropriate legal responses on a variety of levels in a variety of ways," he noted.

"And to have an announcement that comes out that adds challenges and barriers for survivors who are seeking justice is really disheartening."

He said this change to the law sends a social message. 

"There are still people who will see this and that's an impact for them as a potential perpetrator, but then also what message does it send to survivors and people hearing 'well maybe that person was just drunk, maybe I can't report it then, or the courts are not going to believe me," said Pritchard. 

"It sends a lot of really harmful messages even if that's not really what the legal precedent is."

Pritchard added this law change shows that there is more advocating for the perpetrators and accused than there is for victims.  

"Those types of messages are very impactful for people. So, we are hearing from folks that they are really struggling with this decision and they are really feeling like folks are not going to believe them and feeling like the justice system doesn't care about them."

Petitions have been circulating on the internet, including one created by Jill Andrew, MPP for Toronto-St.Paul's.

Pritchard said people should be reaching out to their local representatives and raise concerns about the reformed law.  

A spokesperson for Ontario's Attorney General said the province will be seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.


Cali Doran

About the Author: Cali Doran

Read more
Rogers Media
230 The Boardwalk Kitchener, ON, N2N 0B1 © 2006-2020 Rogers Media. All rights reserved.